Legal Reform, What Reform?

Author: Prof. Dr. Moh. Mahfud MD, SH, SU.

Lecturer at the Faculty of Law Universitas Islam Indonesia (FH UII), Department of Constitutional Law

Before Friday prayers yesterday (October 21, 2016), I was involved in a lively discussion at the Law School of Melbourne University (LSMU), Australia. The event was opened by ISMU professor, Prof. Tim Lindsey, and moderated by LSMU guest professor, Prof. Denny Indrayana. As it was a discussion about current issues, there wasn't a specific topic. However, because it was held at the Law School, the discussion touched on many legal issues.

I was asked to act as the moderator in the discussion and explain several issues related to legal development in Indonesia. I touched on many topics, but remained focused on the current issue facing Indonesia: legal reform. Coincidentally, as the Joko Widodo (Jokowi) and Jusuf Kalla (JK) administration entered its third year, the government announced plans to launch a legal policy package.

In my opinion, entering the third year of the Jokowi-JK administration, the choice of policy packages in the legal sector is appropriate after the government's efforts to address political and economic issues in the first and second years.

Political consolidation in the first year can be considered successful because Jokowi was able to control various political forces and political parties under his control, thus giving him the freedom to determine various programs that could be described in the APBN.

In its second year, the Jokowi-JK administration has clearly attempted to launch various economic policy packages. Overall, it can be said that, despite their relative success, the Jokowi-JK administration has been hampered by legal issues. Many economic policies have been difficult to implement due to legal issues, both due to overlapping legal regulations and due to corruption and collusion in their implementation.

That's why the choice of legal reform policy is crucial and appropriate as a focal point for the Jokowi-JK administration as it enters its third year. For us, upholding the rule of law is key to smooth development in other areas. Upholding the rule of law can already solve half of the nation's various problems, while the remaining half can be divided among other areas and those that can be resolved on an ad hoc basis.

So, the primary solution to our various problems lies in upholding the law first. The logic is simple. So far, the damage to development in various sectors has been caused by a lack of law enforcement. Economic development plans have been undermined by collusion, and corruption eradication has stalled because anti-corruption laws have been enforced in a corrupt manner. Education, healthcare, infrastructure, and trade and commerce have all been damaged by corruption because the law has not been properly enforced.

What still needs to be done in our legal system and reform? In my opinion, what we really need to do is not create new laws, but rather enforce existing ones. If legal development efforts, as Friedman argued, should be directed at three legal subsystems: legal substance, law enforcement officials (legal structure), and legal culture, then what Indonesia needs to improve is law enforcement.

We feel we already have all the legal substance we need. What we lack, or haven't been able to truly implement, is law enforcement. Even though there are legal substance issues that hinder it, these can be resolved linearly through the legislative process (legislative review) or through the judiciary (judicial review), either through the Constitutional Court (MK) or the Supreme Court (MA).

Reform in law enforcement cannot be interpreted as simply tidying up the mess in the judicial system. If law enforcement is defined as the proper implementation of legal provisions, the area of ​​concern extends beyond the judicial system, but rather to the widespread failure to uphold the law within the bureaucracy (government). Specifically, the failure to uphold the law that undermines our government lies in two areas: the judiciary and the day-to-day functioning of the government bureaucracy.

Our bureaucracy is deeply corrupted. It engages in numerous acts of corruption in routine tasks, using procedural manipulation to hide behind manipulated legal regulations. President Jokowi's discovery of extortion at the Ministry of Transportation last week is merely a grain of sand in the vast expanse of our bureaucracy. Such extortion remains commonplace, from the central government to remote areas.

Likewise, our law enforcement in the judicial system is in dire straits. Collusion in case resolution occurs at all levels and involves individuals (who should always be referred to as individuals) from all law enforcement agencies, from judges and prosecutors to police and lawyers. The judiciary, prosecutors' offices, police, and the legal profession, as law enforcers, have sent many of their representatives to prison for violating the law while on duty.

So, if you ask whether legal reform is reformaslapa, the answer is reform of law enforcement (legal structure). The targets are in two areas: the bureaucracy and the judiciary. To address this, strong leadership is needed—strong leadership, strong because it is clean and not held hostage by the mafia, and strong because it dares to take decisive action. That is the red and white leader, a leader who is brave and clean, and also a leader who is brave because it is clean.

Thank you to Professor Tim Lindsay and Professor Denny Indrayana for organizing my lively discussion on law at Melbourne University. I am optimistic that we have many national leaders to build the future of the rule of law in Indonesia, as many of our children studying law share that spirit. For example, I have encountered many of them at various universities during my visit to Australia over the past 10 days.

 

This article was published in the SINDO newspaper, October 22, 2016.